Episode 28

Is AI Making Us Smarter, or Dumbing Us Down?

Key Takeaways

  • Use AI to enhance creative work, not replace it, so every idea still starts with human insight and intent.
  • AI can speed up workflows and cut manual effort, freeing teams to do higher-impact work.
  • Relying on AI too heavily can erode skills in creativity, writing, research and problem solving.
  • Always check AI output. Skipping the review leaves you unable to know whether the answer is right.
  • Be transparent with clients about when AI was used, especially when bidding against competitors for creative work.
  • In regulated fields like telemedicine, AI-made graphics and website chat can feel disingenuous and carry legal risk.
  • Different tools suit different jobs: Claude for research and code, ChatGPT for images, Gemini for video.

Main Topics

1CREATIVITY

How AI can sharpen creative work without taking over the thinking behind it.

2SKILLS

Whether leaning on AI weakens our abilities to write, research and solve problems.

3TRANSPARENCY

Why businesses should disclose AI use to clients and watch for legal and regulatory limits.

Featured Guests

RS

Uses AI to speed up workflows while keeping creative work human-driven.

Ryan Stana
JS

Uses AI for coding and workflow, but keeps it away from patient-facing healthcare experiences.

Joey Stiver
RP

Uses AI sparingly for marketing ideas while protecting his own creativity.

Ron Platt

Meet the Hosts

Elizabeth Gearhart
Elizabeth Gearhart, Ph.D.Chief Marketing Officer, Gearhart Law

Elizabeth Gearhart, Ph.D. is the host of Real AI Use Cases: Business Owners Roundtable, where she explores how businesses are actually putting AI to work. She is also CMO of Gearhart Law and co-host of the nationally syndicated Passage to Profit radio show and podcast.

Richard Gearhart
Richard Gearhart, Esq.Founding Partner, Gearhart Law

Richard Gearhart, Esq. is co-host of Real AI Use Cases: Business Owners Roundtable and founder of Gearhart Law, a full-service intellectual property law firm. A longtime podcaster, he hosts Intellectual Property News and is the host of the nationally syndicated Passage to Profit radio show and podcast.

Elizabeth and Richard share their own experiences with AI slop, unchecked answers and multiple AI tools.

Episode Summary

Frequently Asked Questions

Is AI making people smarter or dumbing them down?
The guests see both sides. AI can speed up work and offer new perspectives, but relying on it too much can weaken creativity, writing, research and problem solving.
How can businesses use AI without losing creativity?
Ryan Stana says his company uses AI to enhance creative capabilities, not replace them, so stories and experiences are still driven by human insight, imagination and intent.
Why should businesses tell clients when they use AI?
Ryan Stana explains that competitors may pitch AI-generated designs as original work, so his company signs off with clients on what is real design work and calls out any AI use up front.
Why does one guest avoid AI in healthcare marketing?
Joey Stiver says patients want a direct connection with a doctor or care member, and regulators have questioned misleading ads, so AI graphics and chat can feel disingenuous in telemedicine.
Which AI tools do the hosts and guests use?
They mention ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Descript and Manus. Elizabeth uses Claude for research and schema code, ChatGPT for images and Gemini for video.
What is the risk of not checking AI output?
Richard Gearhart describes plugging financial models into an AI tool without reviewing them, which raised the question of how he could know the answer was right.

Episode Transcript

View Full Transcript

Business Owners Roundtable. I am going to ask each of our guests one way that they are using AI, or if they are not using it, they can say that too. Then we are going to have a roundtable discussion about AI and its uses. I am going to start with Ryan Stana, with rwsglobal.com. What is your most recent way of using AI in your business?

I would say our business is based on creativity, so we use AI to enhance our creative capabilities, not replace them, which is really important. Every story we tell and every experience we design is driven by human insight, imagination and intent. We are really on the streamlining side of operations. We are using AI to speed up workflows and reduce that manual lift, which allows our team members to have higher impact, do more meaningful work and focus on the creative outcome.

Excellent. And Joey Stiver with joinamble.com. What is one way you are using AI?

AI has helped us work harder, faster and perhaps more efficiently on the coding side, the development and workflow. On the patient-facing side, though, when someone comes to our website for care or to ask a question, that is the last thing they want to see. They do not want to feel like there is a barrier between them and a doctor, care member or practitioner. So AI is a big turnoff when it comes to the patient experience on the front end of the website. The third point is that through my foundation, the Dismas Accelerator, we use AI to teach individuals higher-value skills so that they can go into the workplace, leverage some AI or tech background and perhaps get a better job.

That is excellent. Ron Platt with nasdf.org. What is one way you are using AI?

When you are a solo entrepreneur, you have to come up with creative ideas quickly. As creative as I am, sometimes I reach out to AI and say I need to put a commercial together that does this, or an ad that does this, and it gives me possibly better ways to market the product because it sees it from a different perspective than I do. Especially if I am going after family law firms, or people who are getting a divorce or single families, each one is a separate category and it helps me clarify the marketing toward that specific category. My co-founder absolutely hates it. I have to make sure she is not looking over my shoulder, because then she gives me a whole lecture about it. And she is right about the resources AI takes, the water and the electricity. I get it, and I use it on a limited basis because I also do not want my own brain to rot. I like to know that I can still come up with creative ideas, but it does give me a different perspective that I might not have thought of, and I appreciate that.

I think there is something to be said for using your brain. As we get more into AI, people are going to think less for themselves, because they will rely on it to think for them. It is too soon to realize the effect, but even with a resume, or kids writing reports these days, they just go to AI to have the report written and lose the ability to learn how to write a proper report or do research. We will come back to that, Ron. Richard Gearhart, what is one way you are using AI lately?

We are looking for a new CFO, someone who is good at financial modeling and projecting. We have talked with some people and asked them for redacted spreadsheets showing their modeling as we try to grow the law firm. Instead of actually looking at the models, I plug them into an LLM and ask which of these models best reflects what would happen at Gearhart Law and what we would need to do to scale the business. It does a comparison and analysis, and I do not even look at it. On the one hand I think that is great, but to Ron’s point, I did not look at it, so how do I even know it is right? It needs to be double-checked. I am losing skills because I am letting ChatGPT do something that maybe I should be doing.

For me, Elizabeth Gearhart with Gear Media Studios, which I think I will eventually be calling Gear Media Labs, I have been doing a lot of research for a presentation in July. It is a basic presentation on how to use AI for a certain group, but I thought I should include a little about AI visibility. I have been using Gemini, Claude and ChatGPT, adding my own insights from being CMO for Gearhart Law, and having them look at the presentation and give feedback. There is one slide they all hate and want me to take out, and I said no. It is the slide on AI slop.

I went through Gemini and got a whole explanation that directories help a lot with LLM search. Then I decided to test it myself. I put in a couple of people, one in a directory and one not, and had the answer engines say which one was better. When I asked whether being in a directory affected their opinion, they said very little. When I went back to look for the Gemini conversation that had told me all this, it was gone. I had copied it into a Word document, so I put that into Gemini and asked it to find this, and it said I had erased it. I had not. It was crazy.

There may be humans reading some of this, but if there is human oversight, that is a lot of work. Sometimes you can type in, hello, is anybody there, and see what kind of response you get. Which one do you like to use the most?

I use ChatGPT. It gets to a point where it says if you want more, you have to pay for it, and I am not there yet, so I will go to another one. But ChatGPT is already beginning to know my business model, so when I ask a question it goes back to my company and says what might be pertinent. I keep sticking with the same one at this point.

Same with myself with ChatGPT. As a business holistically, we are in the process of only allowing one program internationally for our employees on company-owned devices. Is that going to be ChatGPT? I actually have no idea. IT is in the midst of finalizing that right now.

On my phone I have Perplexity, where I can click the side button and the app pops up. I started as a ChatGPT user and got the business version. I think I am slowly graduating and evolving into Claude. But I think each has a best use case and a little bit of upside.

What about you, Richard?

It depends what mood I am in. If I am in a serious business mood, then probably Claude or Perplexity. If I need a little shoring up, I go to ChatGPT and it tells me everything I do is wonderful. You are acting like a pro. Only a pro would ask a question like that. It makes you feel good.

I use them all for different purposes. For something that is really deep research, more mathematically oriented, or to generate schema code, I use Claude. I like ChatGPT for image generation, which has gotten really good lately. I do a lot with video because of everything we do, and Gemini is better for that. Gemini gives you the most tokens and handles video best. I think Claude is the most factual.

When you say video, are you creating AI-generated videos or editing them?

It is more video editing. For this podcast, we will take it and put it into Descript, an AI program for editing videos, and make YouTube videos out of it. But if I wanted Gemini to evaluate my video for YouTube and tell me whether it will be a good video, I would use Gemini, because it is easier to upload to.

I do want to go back to Ron’s point about people’s brains turning to mush because they depend on AI too much.

I do not have a need to use it very often. I have been an entrepreneur for over 30 years, so there is a lot of knowledge in this head. I am also very creative, like Ryan. My ability to create comes in my written word, or in designing an advertising brochure or directing a video. If I relied on AI too much, it would take that away from me and my creativity would diminish. Every time I sit down to write an ad, it gets my juices flowing and I do not want to have that taken away. I think if we rely on it too much, our ability to create, think and solve problems becomes lessened, and it dumbs us down. That is my personal opinion.

From a legal standpoint, we as a business need to know how we state that we are using AI. A lot of companies we bid against internationally will go into a room and present a design that is completely pulled from AI design work. So before we pitch, we sign off with our clients on something that says what they are getting from us is real design work, not AI design work, and here is how we will work from a legal standpoint on delivering it. We have to call out when we do use AI. If we get a last-minute request, we will go into the meeting and say, because you called us 30 minutes ago, here is a visual of what this would be, this was done with AI, and if you sign off on this extra spend we will go back and design it the correct way. As individuals and as companies, we need to learn how to navigate that and call it out when AI has been used.

That transparency is absolutely essential. I used AI to design our firm mailbox, because we have a very distinct color scheme on our building. The building is called Innovation Plaza, and it came up with lettering for Gearhart Law, Gear Media Studios, and the words patents, video, innovation. I thought that was really cool, but then I wondered whether the post office has regulations that prohibit advertising on mailboxes. They do, and that is why you have never seen it. I had already painted the mailbox and ordered the letters. Then I found out the post office would probably arrest me for putting advertising on our mailbox. So to Ryan’s point about the legalities, you have to make sure AI does not send you in the wrong direction.

I want to ask the brain mush question of Joey, because he has not had a chance yet.

For us in telemedicine and health, it is difficult. A number of attorneys general sent letters to Meta saying that consumer ads showing a better body or someone with muscles alongside prescription drugs are deceiving to the consumer. So we use practically no AI when it comes to graphics and photos, because there is a lot of red tape around it. In some cases it can come off as a little disingenuous when it does not connect as well with the consumer. It just feels like someone took a shortcut.

I use it for images for my blog, the podcast and YouTube, because ChatGPT can make great images, and I do not pretend I could do what it does. I say on my blog that I optimized the post using ChatGPT, because I put my blogs through it and ask it to optimize for LLM search. Sometimes it changes things and I have to change them back. Then I put it into my blog on Manus, an AI agent that runs my website, and it changes it again and I have to go in and change it back. So I am in a constant battle with these LLMs. This has been Real AI Use Cases.

Keep exploring the show

Hear how more business owners are putting AI to work in their day-to-day.